Smile Aesthetics

Old Amalgam Fillings: Should You Replace Them?

Old Amalgam Fillings: Should You Replace Them?

An amalgam filling that is intact, has no decay underneath and causes no problems does not need to come out: the US FDA advises against removing such fillings just because they contain mercury, since removal costs healthy tooth and briefly increases mercury vapour. Replacing one does make sense when there is decay around it, a crack or broken edge, a cusp that has started to split, or when you simply want a tooth-coloured result. The decision is made tooth by tooth, not for the whole mouth at once.

Do you need to replace it? A quick sort

What the dentist findsReplace?Usual option
Intact filling, tight edges, no decay on the X-rayNo medical needLeave it; check it at your regular visits
Decay under or at the edge of the fillingYesRemove decay and refill, often with a tooth-coloured filling
Broken edge, gap, or a piece missingYesNew filling, or a crown if little tooth is left
Crack lines in the tooth, pain when bitingUsuallyOften a crown to hold the tooth together
Dark filling visible when you smileYour choiceTooth-coloured filling or ceramic restoration

Why is amalgam being phased out?

The European Union phased out the use of dental amalgam from 1 January 2025, mainly to reduce mercury in the environment, with temporary exceptions for countries that need more time and use only for specific medical needs. That is a rule about placing new fillings, not an instruction to drill out existing ones. The FDA in the United States takes a similar line: it lists groups for whom new amalgam fillings may be a concern, such as pregnant women and young children, but says intact amalgam should not be removed for that reason alone.

What does the evidence say about safety and durability?

A 2021 Cochrane review compared amalgam and composite (tooth-coloured) fillings in back teeth. It found low-certainty evidence that composite fillings had almost double the risk of failure (risk ratio 1.89) and a higher risk of new decay at the edges, and it found no consistent, clinically important harms from amalgam. In other words, amalgam is a durable material, and composite is a good one that needs careful technique. That is why an intact amalgam is often best left alone, and why, when it does have to go, the replacement should be planned properly.

When does replacing make sense?

Old amalgam fillings can leak at the edges over the years, and decay can grow underneath them where it is hard to see without an X-ray. Large amalgams also do not bond to the tooth, so the remaining walls can crack, especially in people who grind. In those cases replacement is treatment, not cosmetics. For small and medium cavities a tooth-coloured filling bonds to the tooth and looks natural; our guide to composite fillings explains how it is done. When little tooth is left, a crown protects it better; see the crown guide and E-max or zirconia.

Wanting a tooth-coloured smile is also a fair reason, as long as you know that a healthy tooth gives up a little structure each time a filling is replaced. If staining is what bothers you, compare the options in yellow teeth: whitening, bonding or veneers.

When is replacing the wrong choice?

We replace amalgam fillings regularly, and we still advise against it in some cases. Removing intact, symptom-free fillings to "detox" has no support in the evidence, and drilling out several healthy fillings in one trip removes tooth that cannot be grown back. If you are pregnant or breastfeeding, elective replacement is usually better postponed; see dental treatment during pregnancy. And a filling that is merely old is not a reason in itself: the question is whether it is still sealed and the tooth is sound.

How is it done safely?

The old filling is cut out in pieces with water spray and strong suction, which keeps vapour and particles away from your mouth and lungs, then any decay is removed and the tooth is rebuilt. Ask your dentist how they handle removal; a good clinic answers that question without hesitation. Replacing a few fillings usually fits into one or two appointments; if a filling or crown fails while you are travelling, read crown or filling fell out on holiday.

How do you find out which ones need attention?

An X-ray and a close look at each filling answer the question. You can start before you travel: our page on treatment plans from photos explains what a photo can and cannot show. Send photos or an X-ray on WhatsApp and the written plan arrives within 24 hours, tooth by tooth, or use the contact page.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are amalgam fillings dangerous?

A 2021 Cochrane review found no consistent, clinically important harms from amalgam fillings. The EU phased out new amalgam fillings from 2025 mainly for environmental reasons, and the FDA advises against removing intact amalgam fillings just because they contain mercury.

Should I replace all my amalgam fillings at once?

Usually not. Each filling is judged on its own: replace the ones with decay, cracks or broken edges, or those you want changed for appearance, and leave sound ones alone. Drilling out healthy fillings removes tooth that cannot be replaced.

What replaces an amalgam filling?

For small and medium cavities, a tooth-coloured composite filling bonded to the tooth. When little tooth is left or the tooth is cracking, a crown in zirconia or E-max protects it better.

Does removing amalgam release mercury?

Removal briefly increases mercury vapour, which is one reason the FDA advises against removing intact fillings. When removal is needed, it is done in pieces with water spray and strong suction.

Is composite as durable as amalgam?

Not always. The 2021 Cochrane review found low-certainty evidence that composite fillings had almost double the risk of failure of amalgam in back teeth. Good technique and the right indication matter, and large cavities often do better with a crown.

I am pregnant. Should I replace my amalgam fillings now?

Elective replacement is usually better postponed until after pregnancy and breastfeeding. The FDA says intact amalgam should not be removed in sensitive groups for the sake of removal alone. Decay or a broken filling is a different matter and is treated.

How many appointments does it take?

Replacing a few fillings usually fits into one or two appointments. Crowns take longer because a laboratory makes them. Send photos or an X-ray to WhatsApp +90 530 575 47 18 for a written plan within 24 hours.

Sources

All articles